Answer: Assalamu alaikum wr wb,

Different opinions about hisorical events should not make us confused. Many historians say that Hadhrat Qasim got married in Karbala as it is recited in Majlises, so, we do not take one scholar’s statement for granted like Quran or Ma’sooms statements. Many books contain details of the tragedy of Karbala in cluding Bihar al Anwar by Majlisi, Maqtal Abi Makhnaf, Maqtal al-Khawarizmi, Al-Lohoof by Ibn Taawoos and many other books.

We should not make such matters (like the marriage of Hadhrat Qasim) as an issue causing dispute among Mo’mineen. We should focus on mourning the tragedy, getting its great aims and teaching ourselves and others the great lessons of self purification and justice. Even if one can prove that a certain incident did not happen in Karbala, we should always have the possibilty of other scholars reaching to a different result, so, we do not make it an issue of dispute, unless it carries an insult to our respected leaders and our high values of Islam.

 

 

I hope people will understand what he said? By creating dispupe we first support iblees and I am sure not a single god fearing shia would like to support Iblees.

 

wassalam