Sorry, I went into detail about the part you went into detail about, which was using the ACR 4.4 profile in the new ACR versions and it wasn't clear what the question was, other than hoping Tom would keep his script up-to-date, which he hasn't been.
If your question is about whether to update the jsx code to think 4.4.1 is supported, yes, go ahead. I have had to do this with every release of ACR since Tom does not do it in a timely manner, anymore.
ACRC being compatible with a particular version of ACR mainly means it understands how to reset the various sliders that aren't part of the calibration process (Clarity, Vibrance, Split Toning, Linear Toning Curve, etc) to their zero or default values and there is a potential for a new ACR version to have new sliders and even have old sliders removed, and without a compatibility review for each new version of ACR the script might either miss resetting newly added sliders or accidentally try to reset sliders that no longer existed.
The good news about the versions of ACR since Tom released his last update in January, is that the ACR sliders didn't change since then, so you can merely update the code to include the newest version of ACR in the list of supported versions and run fully compatible.
The bad news is that there are several places to update the version number, but when he added support for 4.2 and 4.3.1 to the January version, he missed two of the three places, so while the script seemed to be compatible, it was really not, meaning it doesn't reset any of the sliders to zero or defaults and you have to do it, yourself.
Since you are comfortable updating the code, double-click on the jsx file (from Windows Explorer) to open it in the ExtendScript Toolkit editor, search for "4.1" and add the current version of ACR to the supportedVersions array initializer list in the three places you find it (just after lines 100, 400 and 450). If you search for 4.3.1 you will only find one place, and all three places need updated, as you can tell by looking at the comments.
Back in January I sent an e-mail to Tom about 2 of the three places being missed, and he agreed it was a bug, but said he was on the road so couldn't fix it immediately, and now its June and still the bug remains.
From using the Lightroom 2.0 beta, it is clear ACR5 will have some more things to reset--at least the localized dodge/burn/saturation paintbrush, so the current script won't be resetting everything it should, but as long as you reset things, yourself (perhaps with a Preset), you could update the code so it thinks its compatible and have it reset most things, still.
I am also suspicious the camera calibration may be changing where Photoshop and Lightroom and may support automated calibration and/or ICM files, where scripts like Tom's may be obsolete or at least need extensive revision. My suspicion is based on comments by Adobe insider Jeff Schewe a couple months ago:
http://www.adobe.com/cfusion/webforums/forum/messageview.cfm?forumid=...
----- Original Message -----
From: egilbert
To: AcrCalibrator
Sent: Wednesday, June 04, 2008 9:47 AM
Subject: [acrcal] Re: AcrCalibrator Updates for ACR 4.4.1 / LR 1.4.1
Ummmm.... thanks for the reply, but it misses my point.
I know how to set the ACR default to use the new profile. I want to
use AcrCalibrator to create new calibration settings for the new
profile(s) in ACR 4.4. However, AcrCalibrator is coded to only allow
function with "supported" versions of ACR, and for the most current
version of AcrCalibrator available for download (v1.2 x114),
"supported versions" of ACR only includes up to 4.3.1. AcrCalibrator
needs to be validated against and updated to include 4.4 and 4.4.1 as
"supported versions", in order to have it run cleanly against these
versions of ACR for calibrating against the new ACR 4.4 profiles.
If I knew for a fact that ACR 1.2 (x114) was 100% compatible with ACR
4.4/4.4.1, I could update the script file myself to include these
versions in the "supported versions" list. My problem is that I do not
know what else Tom usually does to validate his script against updated
versions of ACR prior to adding them to the list of "supported
versions".
Help?
/eddie